My thoughts on whatever happens to wander through my mind
 
 
 
Local links
 
Other links
 
 
 
Texas blogs
 
 
 
Blogroll - Blogroll Me!
 
 
Monday, September 20, 2004
 
The upshot of the CBS forged memo controversy

CBS News has finally come to their senses and admitted what sane and rational people have known for over a week: they shouldn't have aired Dan Rather's 60 Minutes II report on President Bush's Texas Air National Guard service over thirty years ago.

Again, I have to congratulate my buddy Bill (the hardest working blogger in the greater DC area, in my humble opinion — and yes, Bill, that's certainly worth acknowledging in a post of your own, linking back to this post. Just in case you were wondering.), The Three Stooges John, Scott and Paul (just kidding, guys — it leapt into my mind and I just had to use it) at Power Line, Little Green Charles, Allah and others for the insightful and diligent work they've put into covering this story.

While CBS has admitted many shortcomings in creating and prolonging this controversy, there's something else I wish they'd admit: they, primarily Dan Rather and producer Mary Mapes, began with a conclusion and built their story to support their preconceived notion. Rather (no pun intended) than deciding on a story, then pursuing the leads, gathering the information and doing all that other Journalist Stuff ™ and letting the research guide the conclusion, they decided they wanted to slam President Bush, and focused on information that supported their predetermined conclusion and ignored anything that refuted it.

Okay, that's never going to happen. But I hope that they at least do a little introspection, and admit, if only to themselves, that maybe they're letting their own opinions and biases seep into their journalism.

Yeah, it's a wild dream, but it's mine.

Update: The Commissar continues the investigation. He will not be deterred.

Update 2: Scott Nolte just wants Rather to apologize to the President, but feels like that's peanuts compared to my "dream." Honestly, I think my scenario is several orders of magnitude more likely than Scott's.


 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Site search

Powered by:

 
 
 
This page is powered by Blogger, the easy way to update your web site.
 
   
   
 
Blogarama - The Blog Directory
 
   
 
 
 
 
In loving memory
Dr Edward N Garrett
1925 - 2004
 

Home  |  Archives
 
  
© 2002-2008 Boyd D Garrett Sr